Philosophical renovation in the 3rd century: The polemical component of Porphyry’s Vita Plotini in relation to Gregory of Neocaesaria’s Oratio Panegyrica

Authors

  • Roman S. Soloviev Moscow Theological Academy, Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius, Sergiev Posad, Moscow Region, 141300, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0833-0624

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu20.2023.102

Abstract

This paper offers an analysis of similar and parallel developing projects of creating a true philosophy by the disciples and followers of Origen and Plotinus. Two texts permeated by the eulogy of the scholarch are analysed: Gregory the Wonderworker’s The Address of Thanksgiving to Origen and the Life of Plotinus by Porphyry. Gregory was a student of Origen, while Porphyry attended his school long enough to become familiar with the doctrine, teaching methods and personality of the scholarch. The author establishes the structural, thematic and lexical similarity of both texts. The text by Gregory the Wonderworker, chronologically earlier, was a pushing away point for Porphyry in creating an image of the ideal scholarch in the person of Plotinus. This is confirmed by the structural and lexical contrast in the portrayal of Plotinus in Vita Plotini and Origen in the passage preserved by Proclus (Procl. In Tim. I.63. 29–33). In particular, the negative image of Origen in Vita Plotini 13. 10–17 is echoed by the figure of Thaumasius, dissatisfied with the protracted dispute between Plotinus and Porphyry, which rarely draws the scholars’ attention. Nowhere else mentioned, Thaumasius appears as a marginal figure: either he himself was interested in general statements and wanted to hear Plotinus speaking in the manner of a set treatise (trans. Armstrong), or he wanted Plotinus to “faire une conférence suivie et propre à être écrite” (trans. Bréhier). The author hypothesises that it is not a proper name but a nickname. The author suggests that Thaumasius is not an accidental participant in a specific episode of the Neoplatonists’ school life but the philosophical rival of the Neoplatonists, theologian Origen, ironically presented in an unattractive manner. Thus, the deliberately constructed episode with Plotinus and Thaumasius is a polemical jab at Origen’s followers, who put forward a programme of philosophical renovation alternative to the Platonic, and the very depiction of Plotinus as a ‘divine man’ (θεῖος ἀνήρ) responds to the image of Origen painted by his followers. The supposed allusions in Vita Plotini 13. 5–17 testify to the openness of the Roman Neoplatonic school to the already-formed Christian version of philosophy. For this reason, Porphyry chose to portray a situation in which Plotinus showed attention and patience in interpreting difficult philosophical questions for three days. In contrast, Origen, in a similar situation, showed impatience and irritability.

Keywords:

Neoplatonism, Porphyry, Life of Plotinus, Thaumasius, Gregory of Neocaesarea, Oratio Panegyrica, Origen

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

von Albrecht M., Dillon J., George M., DuToit D., Lurje M. Jamblich, Pythagoras: Legende — Lehre — Lebensgestaltung. Eingeleitet, übersetzt und mit interpretierenden Essays. Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 2002.

Alieva O. Origen’s Protreptics to Philosophy: Testimony of Gregory Thaumaturgus in the Oratio Panegyrica, VI, in: A.-Ch. Jacobsen, A. Leuven (eds) Origeniana Undecima: Origen and Origenism in the History of Western Thought: papers of the 11th International Origen Congress, Aarhus University, 26–31 August. Paris, Bristol, 2013, 681–689.

Armstrong A. H. (ed.) Porphyry. The Life of Plotinus, in: Plotinus in seven volumes. Vol. 1: Porphyry on the Life of Plotinus and the order of his books. Enneads I, 1–9. Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1966, 1–87.

Beatrice P. F. Porphyrius, in: Theologische Realenzyklopädie 1997, 27, 54–59.

Beatrice P. F. Porphyry at Origen’s School at Caesarea, in: B. Bitton-Ashkelony, O. Irshai, A. Kofski et al. (eds) Origeniana duodecima. Origen’s legacy in the Holy Land — a tale of three cities. Leuven, Peters, 2019, 267–284.

Beutler R. Porphyrios (21), in: RE 1953, XXII/1, 275–313.

Bidez J. Vie de Porphyre: le philosophe néo-platonicien, avec les fragments des traités Peri agalmatòn et De regressu animae. Hildesheim, G. Olm, 1964 (11913).

Den Boer W. A Pagan Historian and His Enemies: Porphyry against the Christians. Classical Philology 1974, 69, 198–208.

Bradshaw D. The Logoi of Beings in Greek Patristic Thought, in: B. Foltz, J. Chryssavgis (eds) Toward an Ecology of Transfiguration: Orthodox Christian Perspectives on Environment, Nature, and Creation. New York, Fordham University Press, 2013, 9–22.

Bréhier E. (ed.) Porphyre, La vie de Plotin et l’ordre de ses écrits, in: Plotin. Ennéades. Texte établi et traduit par E.
Bréhier. Paris, Les Belles Lettres, 1924, 1–31.

Brisson L. et al. (eds) Porphyre. La Vie de Plotin, Etudes d’introduction, texte grecque etc. T. I. Paris, Vrin, 1982.

Brisson L. (ed.-in-chief) Porphyre. La Vie de Plotin, Etudes d’introduction, texte grecque etc. T. II. Paris, Vrin, 1992.

Celia F. Il logos kephalaiodes dello ps.-Gregorio il Taumaturgo: uno status quaestionis e un primo approccio al problema delle fonti, in: Adamantius 2011, 17, 164–190.

Celia F. Gregory of Neocaesarea: a re-examination of the biographical issue, in: Adamantius 2016, 22, 171–193.

Celia F. Studying the Scriptures at the School of Caesarea: The Testimony of Gregory of Neocaesarea’s Oratio Panegyrica, in: B. Bitton-Ashkelony, O. Irshai, A. Kofski et al. (eds) Origeniana duodecima. Origen’s legacy in the Holy Land — a tale of three cities. Leuven, 2019, 285–295.

Crocke B. Porphyry’s Anti-Christian Chronology. Journal of Theological Studies 1983, 34 (1), 168–195.

Crouzel H. (ed., transl., comm.) Grégoire le Thaumaturge. Remerciement à Origène suivi de La Lettre d’Origène à Grégoire. Paris, Éditions du Cerf, 1969.

Digeser E. D. A Threat to Public Piety. Christians, Philosophers and the Great Persecution. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press, 2012.

Dörrie H. Porphyrios’ “Symmikta Zetemata”, Ihre Stellung in System und Geschichte des Neuplatonismus nebst einem Kommentar zu den Fragmenten. München, C. H. Beck, 1959.

Edwards M. (ed.) Neoplatonic Saints: The Lives of Plotinus and Proclus by Their Students. Liverpool, Liverpool University Press, 2000.

Harder R. Porphyrios: Über Plotins Leben und über die Ordnung seiner Schriften, in: Plotins Schriften, übersetzt von R. Harder, Bd. 5c: Anhang, Hamburg, Meiner, 1958, 1–68.

von Harnack A. (ed.) Porphyrius. Gegen die Christen. Berlin, Reimer, 1916.

Jerphagnon L. Les sous-entendus antichrétiens de la Vita Plotini, ou l’évangile de Plotin selon Porphyre. MH 1990, 47, 41–52.

Johnson A. P. Religion and Identity in Porphyry of Tyre: The Limits of Hellenism in Late Antiquity, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2013.

Kennedy G. A. Classical Rhetoric and its Christian and Secular Tradition from Ancient to Modem Times. London, Croom Helm, 1980, 140–141.

Kinzig W. War der Neuplatoniker Porphyrios ursprünglich Christ?, in: M. Baumbach — H. Köhler — A. M. Ritter (eds) Mousopolos Stephanos. Festschrift für Herwig Görgemanns, Heidelberg, Winter, 1998, 320–332.

Klein R. (ed.), Guyot P. (transl.) Gregor der Wundertäter: Oratio prosphonetica ac panegyrica in Origenem/ Dankrede an Origenes. Im Anhang: Origenis epistula ad Gregorium Thaumaturgum / Der Brief des Origenes an Gregor den Wundertäter. Freiburg i. Br., Herder, 1996.

de Labriolle P., Zeiller J. La Réaction païenne: étude sur la polémique antichrétienne du Ier au VIe siècle. Paris, L’Artisan du livre, 1948.

Miller P. C. Biography in Late Antiquity: A Quest for the Holy Man. Berkeley, University of California Press, 1983.

Monaci Castagno A. Origene direttore d’anime, in: M. Catto, I. Gagliardi, R. M. Parrinello (eds) Direzione spirituale tra tortodossia ed eresia. Dalle scuole filosofiche antiche al Novecento, Brescia, Morcelliana, 2002, 61–85.

Nautin P. Origène. Sa vie et son oeuvre. Paris, Beauchesne, 1977.

Nock A. D., Rothschild C. K. Conversion: The Old and the New in Religion from Alexander the Great to Augustine of Hippo. Waco — Texas, Baylor University Press, 2019 (11933).

Des Places E. (ed.) Porphyrius. Vie de Pythagore. Paris, Les Belles Lettres, 1982.

Ramelli I. Origen and the Platonic Tradition. Religions 2017, 8 (2), 1–21.

Réville A. Apollonius of Tyana, the pagan Christ of the third century. London, J. C. Hotten, 1866.

Richard M. ΑΠΟ ΦΩΝΗΣ. Byzantion 1950, 20, 191–222.

Rizzi M. (ed.) Gregorio il Taumaturgo (?), Encomio di Origene. Milano, Paoline Editoriale Libri, 2002.

Schroeder F. M. Ammonios Saccas, in: ANRW 1987, 36/1, 493–526.

Schwartz E., Mommsen Th., Winkelmann F. Die Kirchengeschichte. Band 2, Teil 1–3. Berlin — New York, De Gruyter, 1999.

Shichalin Yu. The Traditional View of Late Platonism as a Self-contained System, in: M. Vinzent (ed.) Studia Patristica. Vol. LXII. Papers presented at the Sixteenth International Conference on Patristic Studies held in Oxford 2011. Volume 10: The Genres of Late Antique Literature, 2013, 3–9.

Slusser M. (transl.) St. Gregory Thaumaturgus: Life and Works. Washington, Catholic University of America Press, 1998.

Smith A. (ed.) Porphyrii philosophi fragmenta. Fragmenta arabica D. Wasserstein interpretante. Stuttgart — Leipzig, Teubner, 1993.

Soloviev R. Special features of the genre of the “Vita Plotini”: who was Porphyry referring to? Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia III: Filologiia 2022, 73, 84–102 (In Russian).

Tarrant H. Proclus. Commentary on Plato’s Timaeus. Vol. I: Book I: Proclus on the Socratic State and Atlantis. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2007.

Trigg J. W. God’s Marvelous Oikonomia: Reflections on Origen’s Understanding of Divine and Human Pedagogy in the Address Ascribed to Gregory Thaumaturgus. Journal of Early Christian Studies 2001, 9, 27–52.

Westermann A. Porphyrii De Vita Plotini? in: Cobet, C. G., Westermann, A, Boissonade J. F. (ed.) Diogenis Laertii De clarorum philosophorum vitis, dogmatibus et apophthegmatibus libri decem. Paris, Didot, 1850, 102–118.

Wilken R. L. The Christians As the Romans Saw Them. New Haven, Yale University Press, 1986.

Downloads

Published

2023-08-04

How to Cite

Soloviev, R. S. . (2023). Philosophical renovation in the 3rd century: The polemical component of Porphyry’s Vita Plotini in relation to Gregory of Neocaesaria’s Oratio Panegyrica. Philologia Classica, 18(1), 16–32. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu20.2023.102

Issue

Vol. 18 No. 1 (2023)

Section

Graecia antiqua

License

Articles of "Philologia Classica" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.