The Nocturnal Council in Plato’s Laws

Authors

  • Alexander L. Verlinsky St. Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St. Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation; Bibliotheca classica Petropolitana, 9/6, Malyi pr. P. S., St. Petersburg, 197198, Russian Federation

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu20.2016.201

Abstract

The paper discusses the problem of the formation and functions of the Nocturnal Council (NC) in Plato’s Laws, the assembly of the highest officials who have attained advanced philosophical and scientific education. Against the currently prevailing interpretation of the NC (G. Morrow) as the center of scientific and philosophical studies and education in these disciplines, which possesses expert knowledge in the field of laws but does not have legal powers and acts informally through the authority of its members, the senior nomophylakes, the author of the paper argues that 1) there is no textual evidence for the NC as the body that is engaged in studies or performs educational functions: this role is assigned to the school that should be instituted according to 968 c 2 — e 4; the treatment of this piece by some scholars as pointing to the “temporary” formation of the NC should be rejected — the only way of its formation that the text points to is by occupying the highest offices; the NC would be founded in the future and it stands and falls with its taking on persons who have the reputation of philosophically enhanced virtues; 2) the debatable passage 968 c 2 — 7 points not only to the law that should regulate the program of the highest scientific and philosophical studies (as according to Cherniss and Morrow), but also to the law granting legal powers to the NC; 3) these powers are the same as are granted to the NC by the law that constitutes it as the philosophical Guardian of the state (968 a 4- b2), having the task of keeping the laws and the officials aligned with the permanent goal of the state, virtue; 4) the corresponding legal prerogatives of the NC entail the powers of changing the laws (as well as prohibiting persons who do not have philosophically enhanced virtues from being elected as nomophylakes and euthynoi). This interpretation’s seeming contradiction to the provisions made earlier according to which only minimal changes of laws are envisaged and these are assigned to the nomophylakes, not to the NC, can be resolved once it is taken into account that the NC is not part of the constitutional mechanism in the usual sense, but the extraordinary means of making the state permanently follow the philosophical principles on which it is built, the optional provision for the future. Lacking an NC, the city of Magnesia should keep the code of laws as rigid as possible; it will nevertheless be open to danger of imminent moral deterioration.

Keywords:

Plato, the Laws, the Nocturnal Council, Political theory

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

Barker E. Greek Political Theory: Plato and his Predecessors. London, Methuen, 1918.

Bergk T.Platons Gesetze, in: T.Bergk, Fünf Abhandlungen zur Geschichte der griechischen Philosophie und Astronomie. Leipzig, Fues (Reisland), 1883, 41–116.

Bobonich C. Plato’s Utopia Recast: His Later Ethics and Politics. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2002.

Brisson L. Epinomis: Authenticity and authorship, in K. Döring, M. Erler, S. Schorn (eds.) Pseudoplatonica: Akten des Kongresses zu den Pseudoplatonica vom 6.-9. Juli 2003 in Bamberg. Stuttgart, Franz Steiner, 2005, 9–24.

Bruns I. Plato’s Gesetze vor und nach ihrer Herausgabe durch Philippos von Opus, eine kritische Studie. Weimar, Böhlau 1880.

Brunt, P.A.The Model Cities of Plato’s Laws, in: Brunt P.A. Studies in Greek and Roman Thought. Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1993, 245–281.

Bury, R.(ed., tr.), Plato with an English Translation. X.Laws. Vol.I-II.London, Heinemann — New York, Putnam, 1926 (Loeb Classical Library).

Cherniss, H., [Rev.:] G. Müller, Studien zu den platonischen Nomoi. 1951, Gnomon 1953, 25, 367–79.

England, E. B. (ed., comm.), The Laws of Plato: the Text Ed. with Introduction, Notes, etc. Vol. I–II. Manchester, Manchester University Press, 1921.

Gomperz T. Platonische Aufsätze III: Die Komposition der “Gesetze”, Sitzungsberichte der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften: Philosophisch-historische Klasse, 1902. Vienna 1903, 1–36.

Guthrie W. K. C. A History of Greek Philosophy. Vol. V. The Later Plato and the Academy. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1978.

Kahn C.Foreword, in: Morrow G.R. Plato’s Cretan City: A Historical Interpretation of the Laws. Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1993, XVII-XXVIII.

Klosko G. The Nocturnal Council in Plato’s Laws, Political Studies 1988, 36, 74–88.

Klosko G. The Development of Plato’s Political Theory. 2nd rev. ed. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2006.

Klosko G. Knowledge and Law in Plato’s Laws, Political Studies 2008, 56, 456–474.

Klosko G. Knowledge and Law in the Laws: A Response to Xavier Marquez, Political Studies 2011, 59, 204–208.

Laks A. The Laws, in: in C. Rowe, M. Schofield (eds.). The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Political Thought. Cambridge , Cambridge University Press, 2000, 258–292.

Lewis V. B. The Nocturnal Council and Platonic Political Philosophy, History of Political Thought 1998, 19, 1–20.

Lisi F. L. Einheit und Vielheit des platonischen Nomosbegriffes: eine Untersuchung zur Beziehung von Philosophie und Politik bei Platon. Königstein im Taunus, Hain, 1985 (Beiträge zur klassischen Philologie 167).

Lisi F. Die Stellung der Nomoi in Platons Staatslehre. Erwägungen zur Beziehung zwischen Nomoi und Politeia, in: A.Havliček, F.Karfík (eds.), The Republic and the Laws of Plato. Proceedings of the First Symposium Platonicum Pragense. Prague, 1998, 89–105.

Lisi F (tr.), Plató. Diálogos IX.Leyes (Libros VII-XII). Introducción, traducción y notas. Madrid, Editoriial Gredos, 1999.

Marquez X. Knowledge and Law in Plato’s Statesman and Laws: A Response to Klosko, Political Studies 2011, 59, 188–203.

Morrow G.R.Plato’s Cretan City: A Historical Interpretation of the Laws. Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1960, repr. with the new foreword 1993.

Müller G. Studien zu den platonischen Nomoi. Munich, C. H. Beck, 19682 (Zetemata 3).

Piérart, M. Platon et la Cité grecque. Théorie et réalité dans la Constitution des “Lois” . Brussels, Palais des Académies, 1974.

Ritter C. Platos Gesetze: Kommentar zum Griechischen Text. Leipzig, Teubner, 1896.

Samaras T. Plato on Democracy. New York, P. Lang, 2002.

Sier K. Die “nächtliche Versammlung” in Platons Nomoi. Überlegungen zu ihrer Funktion, Politisches Denken. Jahrbuch 2008 = Zehnpfennig, B.(ed.) Die Herrschaft der Gesetze und die Herrschaft des Menschen — Platons Nomoi. Berlin, Duncker & Humblot, 2008, 285–301.

Schofield M. Law and Absolutism in the Republic, Polis 2006, 23/2, 319–327.

Schöpsdau K.(tr., comm.), Platon. Nomoi (Gesetze). Übersetzung und Kommentar. Vol.I-III.Göttingen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1994–2011.

Stalley R. F. An Introduction to Plato’s Laws. Indianapolis, Hackett, 1983.

Susemihl F. Die genetische Entwicklung der platonischen Philosophie. Vol. 2. Pt. 2. Leipzig, Teubner, 1860.

Susemihl F. (tr.), Platon’s Werke. Vierte Gruppe. Vol. 9. Die Gesetze. Vols. I-II. Stuttgart, Metzler, 1862.

Tarán L.(ed., comm.), Academica: Plato, Philip of Opus and the Pseudo-Platonic Epinomis. Philadelphia, American Philosophical Society, 1975 (Memoirs of the American Philosophical Society vol. 107).

Vlastos G. Platonic Studies. 2nd ed. Princeton, Princeton University Press, 19812.

Wallace R. W. ΟΡΘΡΟΣ, TAPhA 1989, 119, 201–207.

Zaicev A.I. Aristotel’ ob otnoshenii “Zakonov” Platona k ego “Gosudarstvu” [Aristotle on the Relation of Plato’s Laws to his Republic] (Pol. II. 1265 a 3–4) (1967), in: Zaitsev A. I. Izbrannye stat’i [Zaicev A. I. Collected Papers]. Ed. by N. A. Almazova and L. Ya. Zhmud. St. Petersburg, Philological Faculty of St. Petersburg State University, 2003, 381–387.

Zaiceva O. I., Gavrilov A. K. Khronologicheskaia kanva zhizni i tvorchestva A. I. Zaitseva [Chronicle of the life and the works of A. I. Zaicev], in: Drevnii mir i my [Ancient World and Us]. Vol. 3. St. Petersburg, Bibliotheca Classica Petropolitana, 2003. 193–210.

Zeller Ed. Philosophie der Griechen, Part II.Sec. 1. Sokrates und Sokratiker. Plato und die Alte Akademie. Tübingen, Fues, 18592; Leipzig, Fues, 18753; with an appendix by E.Hoffmann. Leipzig, Reisland, 19225 (Reprint of the fourth ed. of 1889).

Downloads

Published

2017-03-01

How to Cite

Verlinsky, A. (2017). The Nocturnal Council in Plato’s Laws. Philologia Classica, 11(2), 180–222. https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu20.2016.201

Issue

Vol. 11 No. 2 (2016)

Section

Graecia antiqua

License

Articles of "Philologia Classica" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.